What Is the Hot/Crazy Scale from "How I Met Your Mother"?

Download Article

The dating rule explained, with expert insights

Co-authored by Sabrina Zohar and Dev Murphy, MA

Last Updated: April 30, 2026 Fact Checked

Download Article

• What is the Hot/Crazy Scale?
|
• Origins
|
• Is it accurate?
|
• Should I follow it?
|
• Is it offensive?
|
• More Dating Theories
|
• Video

|Show more |Show less

If you've spent a lot of time online, you've probably heard of the "Hot/Crazy Scale." The theory originated in an episode of How I Met Your Mother back in the mid-2000s, but it's taken on a life of its own as a popular "dating rule" for guys. But what is the rule? Is it accurate? And, well, is it offensive? (Spoiler: yes, it's very offensive!) All these questions and more, answered below!

Hot/Crazy Scale Explained

The Hot/Crazy Scale comes from an episode of How I Met Your Mother. It depicts a woman's attractive-to-crazy ratio, the idea being that a girl is allowed to be crazy as long as she is equally hot. The scale is pretty misogynistic and probably shouldn't be taken seriously as a way to gauge a date's viability.

Steps

Section 1 of 6:

What is the Hot/Crazy Scale?

Download Article

1. 
   The Hot/Crazy Scale is a line graph displaying a woman's attractive-to-crazy ratio. The scale originated in an episode of the sitcom How I Met Your Mother, in which Barney Stinson explains that a girl can be crazy, as long as she is equally hot (or hotter). If she's crazier than she is hot, it's a red flag, and you shouldn't date her. If she's very crazy but super hot, it's thought that her attractiveness will make up for her behavior.

   • The scale tracks "craziness" along the X-axis and "hotness" along the Y-axis.
   • A diagonal line extending from the bottom left corner of the graph (representing minimum hotness and minimum craziness) to the upper right corner (representing maximum hotness and maximum craziness) is known as the Vicky Mendoza Diagonal. (More about Vicky in the next section.)
   • According to Barney, you never want to date someone who rates below the Mendoza Diagonal, as this signifies that they're too crazy and not hot enough to make up for it.
   • The bottom right corner—representing minimum hotness and maximum craziness—is known as the Shelly Gillespie Zone.
   • Dating and relationship coach Sabrina Zohar explains that what the hot/crazy ratio is really saying is that the more attractive someone is, the more the other person will put up with. But she adds, “If that’s your metric of success, you can’t be surprised if you’re disappointed.”
Advertisement

Section 2 of 6:

Hot/Crazy Scale Origins

Download Article

1. 
   The Hot/Crazy Scale first appeared in season 3, episode 5 of How I Met Your Mother. In this episode, called "How I Met Everyone Else," Barney Stinson explains the graph to the gang after Ted introduces them all to Blah Blah, his attractive—but seemingly unstable—girlfriend at the time.

   • Barney explains that the Vicky Mendoza Diagonal—the line extending from the bottom left corner of the graph (representing minimum hotness and minimum craziness)—was named for a girl he dated who "played jump rope with that line": "She'd shave her head, then lose 10 pounds. She'd stab you with a fork, then get a boob job."
   • He also explains that the Shelly Gillespie Zone—the bottom right corner of the graph, representing minimum hotness and maximum craziness—was named for a girl he dated who "gained 20 pounds and tried to kill [him] with a brick."

Section 3 of 6:

Is the Hot/Crazy Scale accurate?

Download Article

1. 
   1
   Some people believe the Hot/Crazy Scale is accurate. While the rule itself is deeply offensive, there's probably some truth to the idea that the more attractive someone is, the more their "crazy" will be tolerated. Essentially, it's "pretty privilege" in action—the idea that people who are deemed more physically attractive are (usually subconsciously) given more leeway when they misbehave.

   • Zohar says that even some good-looking people are “wildly insecure.” She explains that being attractive might get you in the door, but it doesn’t keep you at the table. She adds that sometimes, attractive people were late bloomers, or that all they’ve ever been complimented on is their looks.
   • As Redditor @redditor5789 says, the Hot/Crazy Scale seems accurate "because pretty privilege allows [crazy people] to express [their craziness] with less harsh judgment from others. We're all crazy, but society is quicker to shun the normal-looking ones, so most keep it under wraps."
2. 
   2
   Others believe the rule is exaggerated. As Redditor @el_pinko_grande explains, "It's not really true, it's just that the girls who are both crazy and hot usually end up dating more than their share of guys, so they're overrepresented in the dating pool. The sane hot girls either find a guy pretty quickly or they're really picky about who they date, meaning the general population of guys gets very little exposure to them."

   • It's impossible to really determine the "accuracy" of the scale since it's not rooted in hard logic: Barney takes subjective concepts like "hotness" and "craziness" and tries to apply rational thinking to them, which isn't actually possible.
   • The opposite of pretty privilege is sometimes called "lookism," which therapist Rebecca Tenzer, MAT, MA, LCSW, CCTP, CGCS, CCATP, CCFP, defines as "a form of discrimination based on physical appearance and how closely someone aligns with socially constructed standards of beauty and acceptability…. Individuals whose appearance fits these ideals are more likely to receive social, professional, and economic advantages."
Advertisement

Section 4 of 6:

Should I follow the Hot/Crazy Scale?

Download Article

1. 
   It's probably best not to follow the Hot/Crazy Scale. You likely follow it unconsciously to some degree—it's natural to be unconsciously biased against people we find less attractive. But should you intentionally follow the rule? No: not only is it misogynistic to judge women based on their "craziness" and "hotness" alone, but dating someone who doesn't treat you well—even if they're suuuuuper hot—is going to leave you pretty miserable, and it could even be dangerous.

   • Zohar says that it’s very shallow to say that you can put up with someone being jealous or insecure if they’re attractive, but that you wouldn’t put up with it if they weren’t attractive. She says that means you’re putting looks above more important traits like emotional safety, emotional availability, intelligence, regulation, and the ability to have hard conversations.
   • Dating and relationship coach Kezia Noble points out that we all deserve someone who we're attracted to and who isn't toxic: "A lot of guys might like crazy women, very dramatic women who are very intense," she says. "And I'm like, well, you can get good women who have all those attributes, but in a healthy way: she's passionate. She's intense, but she's very loving also, and she knows where the lines are not to cross."

Section 5 of 6:

Is the Hot-Crazy Scale offensive?

Download Article

1. 
   Yes, the Hot/Crazy Scale is incredibly misogynistic. For one thing, the fact that the scale specifically targets women, and not people in general, is wildly sexist. For another, what's considered "hot" and "crazy" is often subjective. Finally, the scale reduces women's traits to their looks and their level of "hysteria"—which is deeply offensive.

   • As parenting teens expert Kristen Duke points out, women's behavior is often dismissed as "crazy," "dramatic," or "emotional," especially when it's seen as defying traditional gender expectations. That's not to say women can't ever be "crazy," but viewing intimate partnerships through this lens is extremely damaging to women. It's also damaging to the people who date them: you should expect more from your relationships!
   • TL;DR, yes, this rule is offensive—but coming from Barney Stinson, one of the most horrendously misogynistic fictional characters in television history, it shouldn't really come as a surprise.
Advertisement

Section 6 of 6:

Other Dating Rules & Theories

Download Article

1. Check out wikiHow's other articles on dating rules and theories. From the 666 Rule to Rule #5, the internet is full of different and wild dating rules, and wikiHow has broken down many of them for you! Check out these guides for explanations of popular dating rules, how to follow them, and if they're accurate.

   • 666 Dating Rule
   • Rule #5
   • 369 Dating Rule
   • The Olive Theory (another HIMYM classic)
   • Invisible String Theory

Expert Q&A

Search

Add New Question

Ask a Question

200 characters left

Include your email address to get a message when this question is answered.

Submit

Advertisement

Video

Tips

Submit a Tip

All tip submissions are carefully reviewed before being published

Name

Please provide your name and last initial

Submit

Thanks for submitting a tip for review!